Immaculate Movie Review: Sydney Sweeney Shines in Sacrilegious Horror

From the hallowed halls of Catholicism’s most sanctified institutions emerges Immaculate – a searing indictment of blind faith’s darkest transgressions rendered in flesh, blood, and the defiant howls of the profaned. Director Michael Mohan and his incandescent muse Sydney Sweeney conspire to raze the gilded facades behind which the Church’s most unconscionable abuses fester, exposing the grotesque contortions of dogma when unchecked by reason’s light.

Like some unholy hybrid of Dario Argento’s feverish arthouse delirium and the most unrepentant grindhouse sacrilege, Immaculate beckons us to descend into a dank labyrinth where even the sacred miracle of virgin birth warps into an instrument of patriarchal subjugation. Sweeney is our anguished guide, her haunting embodiment of the ill-fated novitiate Cecilia a masterclass in the extremes of human endurance. From the fragile innocence of her earliest scenes to the primal resilience that consumes her in the film’s bravura climax, the rising star charts an exquisite arc of disillusionment and transcendence.

With each frame compositionally steeped in ominous grandeur, Mohan conducts a symphonic escalation of dread that crescendos in visions of unfettered blasphemy. The antiquated splendors of the Italian locales become profane playgrounds where the auteur’s roving camerawork intimates at every unholy rite awaiting revelation. By the time the deranged final act explodes in a bacchanal of subversive fury, even the most jaded audience members will find their nerves scorched by the sanguine excesses. An ecstatic damnation that will either repulse or utterly enthrall depending on one’s appetite for the cinematic sacrilege.

Sydney Sweeney and Benedetta Porcaroli in Immaculate
Sydney Sweeney and Benedetta Porcaroli in Immaculate

What we thought about Immaculate

While Immaculate soars to transcendent heights in its most audacious moments, it remains shackled by the trappings of genre convention. For all its thematic potency as a grand guignol remonstration against the crimes of patriarchal piety, Mohan’s fever dream struggles at times to synthesize substance and subversion into a cohesive vision.

The early passages are plagued by a ponderous predictability that hampers the mounting atmosphere of dread. Insipid jump scares litter the monastic halls, each so telegraphed that they induce more unintentional mockery than genuine terror. The eventual unveiling of the convent’s blasphemous secrets, while undeniably lurid in its baroque grotesquerie, feels like a retread of well-trodden conceits from superior genre predecessors.

Even as it strives to interrogate the institutionalized misogyny and dogmatic control that have enabled millennia of subjugation, Immaculate often defaults to reductive caricatures. The patriarchal villains, though suitably odious in their actions, are thinly sketched authorial mouthpieces rather than fully dimensional adversaries. For all its howls of feminist subversion, the film’s narrative rarely transcends its own dogmatic proclivities.

And yet, for all its creative shortcomings, Immaculate remains a visceral experience that simply must be witnessed if only for its most searing transgressions. Sweeney’s performance alone is worth the price of admission – a harrowing embodiment of resilience clawing its way through the deepest spiritual abyss. When the actress unleashes the soul-lacerating screams of the climax, exorcising every last vestige of pious indoctrination, it is an exquisitely primal spectacle that will scar the psyche.

In such moments of rapturous blasphemy, Mohan’s feverish dirge achieves a transcendent fusion of arthouse grandiosity and grindhouse depravity. The auteur’s meticulous visual design, evoking the grandiloquent flair of 1970s Italian horror whilst remaining utterly modern in its subversive fervor, is nothing short of breathtaking. This is sacrilegious spectacle of the highest order – a defiantly unholy reverie that will speak to the apostate in us all.

Whether one emerges from Immaculate’s delirious rites converted or simply repulsed by its baroque excesses, the experience is undeniably a singular one. Like the most dangerous of heresies, it burrows into the soul and festers there, demanding an ideological reckoning. An act of cinematic immolation that razes comfortable assumptions and leaves only the purifying sting of revelation in its wake.

Sydney Sweeney in Immaculate
Sydney Sweeney in Immaculate

Sydney Sweeny makes the cut

At the scorched heart of Immaculate’s delirious affronteries burns Sydney Sweeney in what can only be described as a tour-de-force of feral resilience. As the ill-fated novitiate Cecilia, the rising star charts an exquisite arc of spiritual immolation – her haunting journey from sheltered innocence to primal avenger is simply staggering in its emotional ferocity.

From the earliest scenes, Sweeney projects an unmistakable aura of childlike purity destined for the most brutal disillusionment. There’s a tremulous fragility to her portrayal of Cecilia’s initial naivete that renders each traumatic revelation all the more shattering. The faintest flickers of doubt etched across her delicately expressive features in the convent’s early passages are like watching the first cracks shudder through a pristine facade soon to be rendered asunder.

As the dark machinations engulfing the monastery gradually encroach, Sweeney’s metamorphosis attains an exquisite slow-burn intensity. Each violation compounds into the next, carving deeper and deeper recesses of anguish across the actress’s soulful countenance. Her eyes, so full of hopeful luminescence in the first act, gradually extinguish into the hollow stare of one who has witnessed the unspeakable depravities of unholy men masquerading as devotees.

It’s a masterful portrayal of escalating torment that renders Cecilia’s climactic confrontation all the more transcendent in its seething defiance. When Sweeney finally unleashes the primal howls that have been gestating from the moment she entered that forsaken place, it is nothing short of a soul-scouring exorcism. An anguished wail that reverberates with the righteous fury of an old order being rent asunder – a spirit reborn amidst the smoldering rubble of blind deference.

Sweeney’s performance is simply breathtaking in these rapturous extremes. A searing embodiment of resilience that burns most fervently when all seems extinguished in the all-consuming darkness. Hers is an indelible representation of the unfettered human spirit, raging against the shackles of antiquated dogma and patriarchal domination with an intensity that sears itself into the cerebral cortex.

For even as Cecilia endures the most depraved violations and her own bodily autonomy is rendered profane by the convent’s blasphemous rites, Sweeney imbues her with an inextinguishable inner light. A radiant defiance that transcends the narrative’s most outlandish convulsions to attain something primal and revelatory about the human soul’s infinite perseverance.

When the screams finally cease and an eerie tranquility descends, the actress’s haunted visage speaks louder than any dialogue of the spiritual conflagration she has endured and overcome.

Michael Mohan and Sydney Sweeney in Immaculate (2024)
Michael Mohan and Sydney Sweeney in Immaculate (2024)

Should you watch Immaculate?

YouTube video

When the unholy rites have reached their delirious crescendo and the sanguine excesses have finally abated, what lingering revelations does Immaculate’s sacrilegious delirium bestow upon the viewer? Is this a profound act of cinematic immolation that scorches away antiquated dogmas? Or merely a maddened descent into gratuitous provocation and genre indulgence?

The truth, as is so often the case, likely lies in the beguiling space between those polar extremes. Michael Mohan’s feverish genre exercise is indeed a work of furious ideological ambition and searing social commentary. At its loftiest aspirations, it emerges as a scathing rebuke of institutionalized patriarchal control and the dogmatic perversion of faith into an instrument of subjugation over the feminine form.

Through the transcendent conduit of Sydney Sweeney’s harrowing performance, the film taps into primal truths about resilience in the face of spiritual annihilation – unfurling visions of inextinguishable human will that burn brightest when plunged into the abyss. These are rapturous moments of subversive revelation that sear themselves indelibly into the psyche.

And yet, for every instance of shattering profundity, there is an equal lapse into shallow genre indulgence that undermines Immaculate’s grander ambitions. Too often the narrative devolves into a pastiche of familiar horror tropes and thinly-sketched patriarchal caricatures perpetuating their atrocities without much dimensionality or nuance. The thematic threads straining to interrogate religious authority and the historical subjugation of female autonomy become tangled amid a disjointed barrage of shocks and convolutions.

By the delirious climax, Mohan seems to abandon subtext entirely in favor of sheer provocation – feverish sequences of graphic ultraviolence and hallucinatory grotesquerie that teeter between the transcendently transgressive and the frankly ludicrous. While certainly mounted with bravura style, these final convulsions struggle to cohere into a cohesive philosophical statement beyond just reveling in the excesses.

And yet, even this tawdry indulgence possesses a distinct power and artistry that demands to be experienced, if not wholeheartedly embraced. Immaculate remains a sensory experience of unholy revelry – a harrowing plunge into rapturous blasphemy that simply must be witnessed on the biggest screen possible. For all its muddled meanings, Mohan’s compositional mastery and baroque visual design evoke the grandiloquent flair of 1970s Italian arthouse terror in a deliriously modernist fusion of arthouse brimstone and grindhouse depravity.

Is the film a masterpiece of subversive horror for our age? Perhaps not in its fully cohesive form. But as a feverish labor of ideological extremity and boundary-pushing spectacle, Immaculate screams out to be witnessed and wrestled with. For the adventurous viewer seeking a dose of unholy revelation cloaked in sacrilegious bravura, Mohan’s sanguine rites undoubtedly slake that thirst in spades.

Just prepare to have your soul seared by the sights and sounds that await within those hallowed halls of unspeakable transgressions. The scarlet sacraments, once partaken, shall never permit the same innocent slumber. An ecstatic damnation that will either repulse or utterly enthrall depending on one’s appetite for the cinematic sacrilege.

So gird your spirit and confront the profane miracle that is Immaculate if you dare. Bask in its raptures or recoil from its excesses – the choice is yours. Just know that once you’ve crossed that immaculate threshold into the abyss of unholy spectacle, there is no turning back to pious mediocrity. You will have tasted the most dangerous of heresies and been forever transformed by its searing revelation.

Immaculate (2024)
Immaculate (2024)