The horror community felt a deep loss when Michelle Trachtenberg passed away on February 26, 2025, at the age of 39. From her breakout role in Buffy the Vampire Slayer to her chilling turns in slasher flicks, she carved out a special place in the genre. Her performances brought a mix of vulnerability and grit that horror fans adored. To celebrate her legacy, we’ve rounded up all her horror movies and shows—plus where you can stream them right now. Grab your flashlight and let’s dive into the darkness she left behind.
Horror Movies That Hit Hard
Black Christmas (2006)
Picture this: snow falling, twinkling lights, and a deranged killer picking off sorority sisters one by one. That’s Black Christmas, where Michelle played Melissa, a loyal friend caught in a holiday nightmare. This 2006 remake of the ’74 classic is a slasher fan’s dream—packed with tension, gore, and that eerie Christmas vibe. Michelle’s presence adds warmth before the chills set in, making it a standout in her horror lineup. (Read the Horror Facts Review: Black Christmas 2006 Remake 15 Years Later.)
- Where to Stream: Prime Video, Shudder, AMC+, Tubi, Pluto TV (select regions)
The Scribbler (2014)
The Scribbler isn’t your standard horror flick—it’s a sci-fi thriller with a dark, twisted soul. Michelle stars as Alice, tangled in a story about a woman wrestling with multiple personalities through a creepy experimental machine. The gothic atmosphere and psychological unease give it a horror edge that sticks with you. It’s weird, it’s wild, and it’s totally worth a watch.
- Where to Stream: Prime Video, Tubi
Horror Shows That Kept Us Hooked
Buffy the Vampire Slayer (1999–2003)
If you’re a horror fan, Buffy needs no introduction. Michelle joined the cast as Dawn Summers, Buffy’s little sister, starting in season four. Things get seriously spooky in season five when Dawn’s revealed as the Key—a mystical entity hunted by demonic forces. From vampires to hellish portals, her role is steeped in supernatural terror, balanced by her heartfelt performance. It’s a binge-worthy classic that never gets old.
- Where to Stream: Hulu, Prime Video, Tubi, Disney+
The Nightmare Room (2001)
Remember those creepy anthology shows from the early 2000s? Michelle popped up in The Nightmare Room’s “The Day the Music Died” episode as Jenny, a violinist tormented by a vengeful spirit. It’s a bite-sized horror treat perfect for fans of quick, spooky thrills—think Goosebumps with an extra edge.
- Where to Stream: Not widely available; check YouTube for episodes.
Grimm (2013)
In Grimm’s “The Kiss” episode, Michelle guest-starred as Juliana, tangled in a tale of a creature that petrifies its victims with a smooch. This horror-fantasy hybrid delivers the creeps, and her cameo adds a dash of star power to the monstrous mayhem.
- Where to Stream: Netflix, Prime Video, Peacock
The Originals (2015)
Vampire fans, this one’s for you. Michelle appeared as Charlotte in The Originals’ “Exquisite Corpse” episode, diving into the bloody, gothic world of New Orleans’ undead. Her brief role amplifies the show’s horror-drama vibes, making it a tasty morsel for fans of fangs and frights.
- Where to Stream: Netflix, Prime Video, HBO Max
Why Her Horror Roles Matter
From the slasher screams of Black Christmas to the supernatural stakes of Buffy, Michelle Trachtenberg brought a unique blend of vulnerability and strength to horror. Her guest spots in Grimm and The Originals showed she could haunt us in small doses, while The Scribbler proved she could handle the weird and unsettling. Her passing, confirmed by People, hits hard, but her work lives on through these chilling performances.
Stream and Scream Tonight
With streaming options aplenty—Hulu, Shudder, Netflix, and more—there’s no excuse not to dive into Michelle’s horror legacy. Whether you’re in the mood for a full-on slasher or a supernatural saga, her roles offer something for every horror hound. So grab your popcorn, dim the lights, and let her eerie brilliance spook you all over again.
What’s your favorite Michelle Trachtenberg horror moment? Drop it in the comments below and let’s keep her memory alive!
